English • Seconde

Reporting Questions and Commands
Reported Speech

Rules & Exercises
\(\text{Direct: "Do you like it?"} \rightarrow \text{Reported: "He asked if/whether I liked it"}\)
Question Reporting Pattern
Yes/No Questions
if/whether
Ask if/whether
Wh-Questions
keep question word
Ask what/where/when
Commands
tell/ask + to do
Tell someone to do
Questions: Yes/No → "if/whether", Wh- → keep question word, normal word order.
💬
Commands: Use "tell/ask/order/advise + object + to + infinitive."
🔍
Word Order: Reported questions use normal subject-verb order, not question order.
🎯
Backshift: Apply tense backshifting to questions and commands as well.
💡
Tip: Questions lose question word order in reported speech
🔍
Caution: Commands use "to" infinitive after reporting verb
Quick Rule: Yes/No → if/whether, Wh- → keep word, Command → tell/ask + to
📋
Method: Identify question type, apply appropriate connector, change word order
Exercise 1
Report yes/no questions
Exercise 2
Report wh-questions
Exercise 3
Report commands and orders
Exercise 4
Report polite requests
Exercise 5
Report suggestions and advice
Exercise 6
Handle negative commands
Exercise 7
Report questions with modal verbs
Exercise 8
Convert reported questions to direct speech
Exercise 9
Handle complex question structures
Exercise 10
Master advanced reporting scenarios
Solutions: Exercises 1 to 5
1 Yes/No Questions
Definition:

Yes/No question reporting: Converting questions that can be answered with yes or no to reported speech using "if" or "whether".

Conversion Method:

Replace question mark with "if/whether", change to normal word order, apply backshift

Step 1: Identify Yes/No Question

Direct: "He said, 'Do you like pizza?'"
"Do you like" is a yes/no question

Step 2: Replace with "If/Whether"

"Do you like" → "if/whether you like"

Step 3: Change Word Order

Question order "Do you like" → Normal order "you like"

Step 4: Apply Backshift

"like" (present) → "liked" (past) because reporting verb is "said"

Step 5: Complete the Reported Speech

"He asked if/whether I liked pizza"

Final Answer:

Direct: "He said, 'Do you like pizza?'" → Reported: "He asked if/whether I liked pizza"

Applied Rules:

Connector Rule: Yes/No questions use "if" or "whether"

Word Order: Change question order to normal subject-verb order

Backshift: Apply appropriate tense backshift

2 Wh-Questions
Definition:

Wh-question reporting: Converting questions starting with question words (what, where, when, etc.) to reported speech keeping the question word.

Step 1: Identify Wh-Question

Direct: "She asked, 'Where do you live?'"
"Where" is the question word

Step 2: Keep Question Word

Retain "where" in reported speech

Step 3: Change Word Order

Question order "Where do you live?" → Normal order "where you live"

Step 4: Apply Backshift

"do you live" → "did you live" → "lived"

Step 5: Complete the Reported Speech

"She asked where I lived"

Final Answer:

Direct: "She asked, 'Where do you live?'" → Reported: "She asked where I lived"

Applied Rules:

Question Word Retention: Keep wh-words in reported speech

Normal Word Order: Change to subject-verb-object order

Backshift Application: Apply appropriate tense changes

3 Commands and Orders
Definition:

Command reporting: Converting imperative sentences to reported speech using "tell/ask/order + object + to + infinitive".

Step 1: Identify Imperative

Direct: "He said, 'Open the door'"
"Open" is an imperative command

Step 2: Choose Appropriate Reporting Verb

"said" → "told" (for commands/orders)

Step 3: Add Indirect Object

"He told me" (assuming "me" is the person addressed)

Step 4: Use "To" + Infinitive

"to open the door"

Step 5: Complete the Reported Speech

"He told me to open the door"

Final Answer:

Direct: "He said, 'Open the door'" → Reported: "He told me to open the door"

Applied Rules:

Structure Pattern: Subject + reporting verb + object + to + infinitive

Reporting Verb Choice: Tell (orders), ask (requests), order (formal commands)

Infinitive Form: Always use "to" + base form of verb

4 Polite Requests
Definition:

Polite request reporting: Converting polite commands using "please" or modal requests to reported speech using "ask + object + to + infinitive".

Step 1: Identify Polite Request

Direct: "She said, 'Please sit down'"
Polite request with "please"

Step 2: Choose Appropriate Reporting Verb

"said" → "asked" (more polite than "told")

Step 3: Add Indirect Object

"She asked me"

Step 4: Use "To" + Infinitive

"to sit down"

Step 5: Alternative with Modal Requests

Direct: "Could you help me?" → "She asked if I could help her"

Final Answer:

Direct: "She said, 'Please sit down'" → Reported: "She asked me to sit down"

Applied Rules:

Politeness Level: Use "ask" for polite requests, "tell" for direct commands

Modal Requests: Treat as questions when using "could/would you"

Context Sensitivity: Consider tone when selecting reporting verb

5 Suggestions and Advice
Definition:

Suggestion/advice reporting: Converting suggestions and advice to reported speech using various structures.

Step 1: Suggestions with "Let's"

Direct: "He said, 'Let's go shopping'"
Reported: "He suggested going shopping"
Or: "He suggested that we should go shopping"

Step 2: Advice with "Should"

Direct: "She said, 'You should study harder'"
Reported: "She advised me to study harder"
Or: "She told me I should study harder"

Step 3: Recommendations

Direct: "He said, 'I recommend buying this book'"
Reported: "He recommended buying this book"
Or: "He recommended that I should buy this book"

Step 4: Different Reporting Verbs

Suggest, recommend, advise, propose, urge, encourage

Final Answer:

Suggestions and advice use reporting verbs like "suggest", "recommend", "advise" followed by gerund or "that" clause with "should".

Applied Rules:

Gerund Structure: Suggest/Recommend + -ing form

That-Clause: Suggest/Recommend + that + subject + should + infinitive

Advice Pattern: Advise + object + to + infinitive

Solutions: Exercises 6 to 10
6 Negative Commands
Definition:

Negative command reporting: Converting negative imperatives to reported speech using "not to" before the infinitive.

Step 1: Identify Negative Command

Direct: "He said, 'Don't smoke here'"
"Don't" indicates negative command

Step 2: Choose Reporting Verb

"said" → "told" (for negative commands)

Step 3: Add Indirect Object

"He told us"

Step 4: Use "Not To" + Infinitive

"not to smoke here"

Step 5: Complete the Reported Speech

"He told us not to smoke here"

Final Answer:

Direct: "He said, 'Don't smoke here'" → Reported: "He told us not to smoke here"

Applied Rules:

Negative Structure: Subject + reporting verb + object + not to + infinitive

Position of "Not": Between object and "to" infinitive

Same Pattern: Follow same structure as positive commands

7 Questions with Modal Verbs
Definition:

Modal question reporting: Converting questions containing modal verbs (can, could, will, would, etc.) to reported speech.

Step 1: Yes/No Modal Questions

Direct: "He asked, 'Can you help me?'"
Reported: "He asked if I could help him"
(can → could)

Step 2: Wh-Modal Questions

Direct: "She asked, 'Where can I park?'"
Reported: "She asked where she could park"
(can → could)

Step 3: Future Modal Questions

Direct: "He asked, 'Will you come tomorrow?'"
Reported: "He asked if I would come the next day"
(will → would)

Step 4: Combined Rules

Apply both question reporting rules AND modal backshift rules

Final Answer:

Modal questions follow both question reporting rules (normal word order, if/whether/wh-word) and modal backshift rules (can→could, will→would, etc.).

Applied Rules:

Double Application: Apply question reporting AND modal backshift rules

Modal Backshift: Can→could, will→would, may→might, etc.

Word Order: Maintain normal word order after modal backshift

8 Converting Back to Direct
Definition:

Reverse conversion: Changing reported questions and commands back to direct speech.

Step 1: Reverse Question Reporting

Reported: "He asked if I liked coffee"
Direct: "He said, 'Do you like coffee?'"
(if → ?, add "do" for present tense)

Step 2: Reverse Wh-Question

Reported: "She asked where I lived"
Direct: "She said, 'Where did you live?'"
(backshift reverse: lived → did you live)

Step 3: Reverse Command

Reported: "He told me to close the door"
Direct: "He said, 'Close the door'"
(remove "to", use imperative)

Step 4: Reverse Negative Command

Reported: "She told us not to run"
Direct: "She said, 'Don't run'"
(add "don't" before verb)

Final Answer:

To convert back: restore question order for questions, remove "to" and use imperative for commands, reverse tense backshift.

Applied Rules:

Reverse Process: Undo backshift and word order changes

Question Restoration: Add auxiliary verbs and question marks

Command Restoration: Remove "to" and use base form

9 Complex Question Structures
Definition:

Complex question reporting: Handling questions with multiple clauses, conditionals, and complex tenses.

Step 1: Indirect Questions with Conditionals

Direct: "He asked, 'Would you go if you had time?'"
Reported: "He asked if I would go if I had time"
(Both clauses backshift)

Step 2: Questions with Perfect Tenses

Direct: "She asked, 'Have you finished your work?'"
Reported: "She asked if I had finished my work"
(Present perfect → Past perfect)

Step 3: Embedded Questions

Direct: "He asked, 'What do you think about this?'"
Reported: "He asked what I thought about it"
(Multiple backshifts)

Step 4: Questions with Reported Speech Inside

Direct: "She asked, 'Did he say, "I will come"?'"
Reported: "She asked if he had said he would come"

Final Answer:

Complex questions require applying reporting rules to each clause independently while maintaining logical relationships and proper backshifting.

Applied Rules:

Clause Independence: Apply rules to each clause separately

Consistent Backshift: Maintain tense logic throughout

Logical Relationships: Preserve conditional and causal connections

10 Advanced Scenarios
Definition:

Advanced mastery: Complex reporting scenarios including mixed question types, multiple embedded clauses, and sophisticated structures.

Step 1: Mixed Question Types

Direct: "He asked, 'Do you like it?' and 'Where did you buy it?'"
Reported: "He asked if I liked it and where I had bought it"
(Two separate reported questions)

Step 2: Commands with Object Clauses

Direct: "She ordered, 'Tell him that you're sorry'"
Reported: "She ordered me to tell him that I was sorry"
(Command + reported speech inside)

Step 3: Hypothetical Questions

Direct: "He asked, 'What would you do if you won the lottery?'"
Reported: "He asked what I would do if I won the lottery"
(Conditional preserved)

Step 4: Time and Place Adjustments

Direct: "He asked, 'Are you here now?'"
Reported: "He asked if I was there then"
(Here→there, now→then)

Step 5: Complex Pronoun Adjustments

Direct: "John told Mary, 'Ask him to call me'"
Reported: "John told Mary to ask him to call him"
(Pronoun reference depends on context)

Final Answer:

Advanced scenarios require careful attention to all reporting rules simultaneously: word order, backshift, pronouns, time/place references, and complex clause relationships.

Applied Rules:

Multi-Rule Application: Apply multiple rules simultaneously

Context Sensitivity: Adjust pronouns and references based on context

Complex Logic: Maintain logical consistency across all elements

Reporting questions and commands Reported Speech